Signal vs Element

A detailed comparison to help you choose between Signal and Element.

Signal

Signal

Private messenger

Element

Element

Decentralized messenger built on Matrix protocol.

Rating4.8 (45000 reviews)4.0 (461 reviews)
Pricing Modelfreefree
Starting PriceFreeFree
Best ForMost secure messagingBest for users seeking privacy and security tools
Free Tier
API Access
Team Features
Open Source
Tags——

Signal

Pros

  • + Free app with optional donations
  • + Publicly documented Signal Protocol specs
  • + Minimal retained data in subpoena examples
  • + Usernames reduce phone-number sharing
  • + Open-source core code on GitHub
  • + End-to-end encrypted group calling design

Cons

  • - Phone number required for registration
  • - Some anti-spam server components reportedly closed
  • - Backup recovery key adds user responsibility
  • - No official performance benchmarks published
View full Signalreview →

Element

Pros

  • + Works across Matrix servers; supports federation
  • + End-to-end encryption supported and encouraged by default
  • + Open-source client code available on GitHub
  • + Secure Backup and device verification for multi-device E2EE
  • + Element Call roadmap for modern voice/video

Cons

  • - Encrypted rooms still expose some metadata to servers
  • - Multi-device encryption setup can be confusing
  • - Enterprise pricing is sales-led, not fully public
  • - Security track record includes past critical client vulnerabilities
View full Elementreview →

Stay in the loop

Get weekly updates on the best new privacy tools, deals, and comparisons.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.