ProtonMail vs Mailbox.org

A detailed comparison to help you choose between ProtonMail and Mailbox.org.

ProtonMail

ProtonMail

End-to-end encrypted email

Mailbox.org

Mailbox.org

Privacy-focused email with PGP support and cloud.

Rating4.6 (20000 reviews)4.2 (213 reviews)
Pricing Modelfreemiumpaid
Starting PriceFrom $0/moFrom $1/mo
Best ForBest encrypted emailBest for users seeking privacy and security tools
Free Tier
API Access
Team Features
Open Source
Tags——

ProtonMail

Pros

  • + Automatic E2EE between Proton Mail users
  • + Zero-access encryption for stored mailbox data
  • + OpenPGP support for external encrypted email
  • + Password-protected encrypted emails to anyone
  • + Open-source client apps with published audits
  • + Inbox tracking protection blocks pixels, hides IP

Cons

  • - Not end-to-end encrypted to non-Proton by default
  • - Metadata and headers aren’t fully encrypted
  • - Can be compelled to log IP under Swiss orders
  • - Free accounts may be deleted after 12 months inactive
View full ProtonMailreview →

Mailbox.org

Pros

  • + Works with IMAP/SMTP/POP3 and CalDAV/CardDAV
  • + Tiered plans include Drive, Office, and Meet
  • + Publishes transparency reports on authority requests
  • + Supports many aliases and custom domains on paid tiers
  • + Drops obsolete TLS versions; modern baseline security

Cons

  • - No free plan; paid service even for basics
  • - YubiKey support reportedly broken with Login 2.0
  • - Not fully open source, per third-party review
  • - ActiveSync has documented limitations vs open protocols
View full Mailbox.orgreview →

Stay in the loop

Get weekly updates on the best new privacy tools, deals, and comparisons.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.