NextDNS vs iCloud Private Relay

A detailed comparison to help you choose between NextDNS and iCloud Private Relay.

NextDNS

NextDNS

DNS-based privacy and security

iCloud Private Relay

iCloud Private Relay

Apple's privacy-focused internet relay for Safari.

Rating4.5 (12000 reviews)4.2 (124 reviews)
Pricing Modelfreemiumpaid
Starting PriceFrom $0/moFrom $0.99/mo
Best ForBest DNS-based ad blockingBest for users seeking privacy and security tools
Free Tier
API Access
Team Features
Open Source
Tags——

NextDNS

Pros

  • + Supports DoH, DoT, DoQ, and DoH3
  • + Configurable logging, retention, and data residency
  • + Open-source MIT-licensed CLI client
  • + Free tier up to 300,000 queries/month
  • + Graceful fallback to basic DNS after quota

Cons

  • - Free tier filtering stops after 300k queries
  • - No independent no-logs audit found in sources
  • - Not a VPN; doesn’t hide your IP address
  • - GUI apps not confirmed open-source
View full NextDNSreview →

iCloud Private Relay

Pros

  • + Two-hop design splits IP and destination visibility
  • + ODoH protects DNS lookups from local networks
  • + Integrated into iOS/iPadOS/macOS as a system feature
  • + Keeps regional IP mapping to reduce site breakage
  • + Included with iCloud+ plans (not a separate app)

Cons

  • - Not a full-device VPN for all app traffic
  • - Doesn’t let you choose another country/region
  • - Can be blocked on work or school networks
  • - Hard to validate logging without a public audit
View full iCloud Private Relayreview →

Stay in the loop

Get weekly updates on the best new privacy tools, deals, and comparisons.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.